Please wait a minute...
北京大学期刊网 | 作者  审稿人  工作人员       
首页     关于     浏览     投稿指南     新闻公告
北京大学教育评论
论文
全球治理与教育变革:跨国与国际教育政策过程研究的重要性
Global Governance and Educational Change: The Importance of Research on Transnational and International Policy Processes in Education

卡伦·芒迪,申超
Karen Mundy and Shen Chao


出版日期: 2011-01-10


PDF
[746 KB]
528
下载
184
浏览

引用导出
0
    /   /   推荐

摘要 大多数教育政策研究仍然把教育政策主要放在国内政治而非国际政治的舞台中进行研究.本文吸收了政治科学、国际关系和公共管理领域最近的研究成果,指出国际的、地区的和跨国的行为主体及其政策过程的影响力正在增长,理应得到教育政策研究界的高度重视.政治科学中的全球治理研究或许能为关于跨国和国际的行为主体及其政策过程的教育政策研究提供新的方法,同时,提醒我们更多地关注新的国际行为体和新的组织与协调方式,更加深入地思考规范化的过程在多大程度上塑造了民族国家对教育中的共同国际利益的认同方式.
关键词 全球治理教育改革政策过程    
Abstract:Most educational policy research continues to frame education policy as an arena of primarily domestic rather than international politics.Drawing on recent research in the fields of political science,international relations,and public administration,this paper suggests that the impact of inter-national,regional and transnational actors and policy processes is growing,and deserves heightened attention from education policy scholarship.Global governance research in political science may offer new ways forward...
Alexander,N. Paying for education:How the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund influence education in developing countries[J].Peabody Journal of Education,2001,(3 - 4):285-338
Anderson,B. Imagined communities[M].New York,Verso,1983
Arnove,R. Philanthropy and Cultural Imperialism:The Foundation at Home and Abroad[M].Boston:C.K.Hall,1980.
Bhanji,Z. Transnational corporations in education:Filling the governance gap through new social norms and market multilateralism[J].Globalisation Societies and Education,2008,(01):55-73
Barnett,M,Duvall,R. Power and global governance[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2005
Barnett,M,Finnemore,M. Rule for the world:International organizations and global politics[M].Ithaca NY:Cornell University Press,2004
Biersteker,T.J,R.B.Hall. Private authority as global governance[A].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2002.3-23
Bull,B,McNeill,D. The rise of public-private partnerships in the multilateral system[A].New York:Routledge,2007.1-22
Carnoy,M. Globalization and educational reform:What planners need to know[M].Paris,International Institute for Education Planning,1999
Castells,M. The power of identity[M].Oxford:Blackwell Publishers Inc,1997
Ceri Jones,H. Lifelong learning in the European Union:Wither the Lisbon strategy[J].European Journal of Education,2005,(03):247-260.
Chabbott,C. Constructing education for development:International organizations and Education for All[M].New York:Routledge Falmer,2003
Chan,J. Between efficiency,capability and recognition:Epistemes in global governance reforms[J].Computer & Education,2007,(03)
Claude,I.L.Jr. Collective legitimization as a political function of the United Nations[J].International Organization,1966,(03):367-379
Cox,R.W. Social forces,states and world orders:Beyond international relations theory[J].Millennium:Journal of International Studies,1981,(02):126-155
Cutler,C,Haufler,V,Porter,T. Private authority and international affairs[M].Albany:State University of New York,1999
Dale,R. Specifying globalization effects on national policy:A focus on mechanisms[J].Journal of Education Policy,1999,(01):1-17
Dale,R. Forms of governance,governmentality and the EU's open method of coordination[A].London:Routledge,2004.174-194
Dale,R,Robertson,S.L. The varying effects of regional organizations as subjects of globalization of education[J].Comparative Education Review,2002,(01):10-36.
De Prado Yepes,C. World regionalization of higher education:policy proposals for international organizations[J].Higher Education Policy,2006,(01):111-128
Edwards,M. Just another emporer.The myths and realities of philanthrocapitalism[OL].http://www.futurepositive.org/emperor.php,2008
Finnemore,M. International organizations as teachers of norms:The United Nations Educational,Scientific and Cultural Organization and Science Policy[J].International Organization,1993,(04):565-597
Finnemore,M. National interests in international society[M].Ithaca,New York:Cornell University Press,1996.
Finnemore,M. Norms,culture and world politics:Insights from sociology's institutionalism[J].International Organization,1996,(02):325-347
Finnemore,M,Sikkink,K. International norm dynamics and political change[J].International Organization,1998,(04):887-917
Fredriksson,U. Studying the supra-national in education:GATS,education and teacher union policies[J].European Educational Research Journal,2004,(02):415-441doi:102304/eerj.2004.3.2.1
Gaventa,J,M.Mayo. Spanning citizenship spaces through transnational coalitions:the Global Campaign for Education[A].London:ZED books,2010
Gilpin,R. War and change in world politics[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1981
Green,A. Education and state formation[M].New York:St.Martin's Press,1990.
Green,A. Education,globalization and the nation state[M].New York:St.Martin's Press,1997
Grek,S. Governing by Numbers:the PISA effect in Europe[J].Journal of Education Policy,2009,(01):23-37
Grek,S,M.Lawn,B.Lingard,J.Ozga,R.Rinne,C.Sigerholm,H.Simola. National Policy brokering and the construction of the European Education Space in England,Sweden,Finland and Scotland[J].Computer & Education,2009,(01):5-21
Held,D. Democracy and the global order:From the modern state to cosmopolitan governance[M].Stanford,California:Stanford University Press,1995
Held,D. At the global crossroads:The end of the Washington Consensus and the rise of global social democracy[J].Globalizations,2005,(01):95-113
Henry,M,Lingard,B,Rizvi,F,Taylor,S. The OECD,globalisation and education policy[M].Oxford:pergamon Press,2001
Heyneman,S. The growing commercial market for educational goods and services[J].International Journal of Educational Development,2001,(04):45-359
Holsti,K.J. The dividing discipline:Hegemony and diversity in international theory[M].Boston:Allen and Unwin,1985
Jolly,R. Adjustment with a human face:A UNICEF record and perspective on the 1980s[J].World Development,1991,(12):1807-1821
Jones,P.W. International policies for Third World education:UNESCO,literacy and development[M].London and New York:Routledge,1988
Jones,P.W. The United Nations and education:Multilateralism,development and globalisation[M].London and New York:RoutledgeFaimer,2005
Jones,P.W. World Bank financing of education:Lending,learning and development [M].London and New York:RoutledgeFaimer,2007
Keck,M,Sikkink,K. Activists beyond borders[M].New York:cornell University Press,1998
Keohane,R.0. International institutions:Two approaches[J].International Studies Quarterly,1988,(04):379-396.
Keohane,R,Nye,J.S. Power and interdependence:World politics in transition[M].Boston:Little and Brown,1977
Kirton,J,Sunderland,L. The G8 and Global Education Governance[A].http://www.g8
utoronto.ca/scholar/kirton2006/kirton_education_060530.pdf,2006.
Klein,N. Reclaiming the commons[J].New Left Review,2001
Knight,J. Higher Education and Trade Agreements-What are the Policy Implications[A].France:Paris,2003
Knight,J. Higher Education in the trade context of GATS[A].Amsterdam,The Netherlands,2005
Knight,J. Higher Education Crossing Borders:A Guide to the Implications of GATS for Cross-border Education[A].France:Paris,2006.
Koenig-Archibugi,M. Understanding the Global Dimensions of Policy[J].Global Policy,2010,(01):16-28doi:101111/j.1758-5899.2009.00009x.
Larsen,K,Martin,J.P,Morris,R. Trade in Educational Services:Trends and Emerging Issues[M].Paris:OECD,2002
Lawn,M,Lingard,B. Constructing the European policy space in educational governance:The role of transnational policy actors[J].European Educational Research Journal,2002,(02):290-307
Lipschutz,R. Global civil society and global governmentality:or the search for politics and the state amidst the capillaries of social power[A].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2004.229-248
Louisy,P. Whose context for what quality.Informing education strategies for the Caribbean[J].Compare:A Journal of Comparative Education,2003,(03):285-292
Mahon,R. After Neo-Liberalism.The OECD,The World Bank and the Child[J].Global Social Policy,2010172-192
Marginson,S. Global position and position taking:The case of Australia[J].JOURNAL OF STUDIES IN INTERNATIONAL EDUCATION,2007,(01):5-32
Marshall,T.H. Citizenship and social class[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1950.
Martens,K,K.D.Wolf. Boomerangs and Trojan Horses:The Unintended Consequences of Internalising Education Policy Through the EU and the OECD[J].Higher Education Dynamics,2009,(02):81-107
Martens,K,C.Balzer. Comparing the Governance of International Organizations:The EU and the OECD,and Educational Policy[A].http://www.essex.ac.uk/ecpr/events/jointsessions/paperarchive/uppsala/wsl/Martens.pdf,2004
Martens,K. Small Country,Big Business.New Zealand as an Education Exporter[J].Computer & Education,2008,(01):3-19
McKinlay,R.D,Little,R. Global problems and world order[M].London:Pinter,1986.
McNeely,C. Prescribing national education policies:The role of international organizations[J].Comparative Education Review,1995,(04):483-507doi:101086/447342
McNeely,C,Cha,Y.K. Worldwide educational convergence through international organizations:avenues for research[J].Education Policy Analysis Archives,1994,(04)
Meyer,J.W. The effects of education as an institution[J].American Journal of Sociology,1977,(01):55-77
Meyer,J.W,Ramirez,F.O. The World Institutionalization of Education.Jugen Schriewer[A].New York:Peter Lang Publishing,Inc,2000.111-132
Meyer,J.W,Boli,J,Thomas,G.M,Ramirez,F.O. World society and the nation state[J].American Journal of Sociology,1997,(01):144-181
Milner,H. International theories of cooperation among nations:Strengths and weaknesses[J].World Politics,1992,(03):466-496.
Morgenthau,W. Politics among nations[M].New York:Knopf,1967
Mundy,K. Educational multilateralism and world (dis)order[J].Comparative Education Review,1998,(04):448-478
Mundy,K. UNESCO and the limits of the possible[J].International Journal of Educational Development,1999,(01):27-52
Mundy,K. Education in a reformed World Bank[J].International Journal of Educational Development,2002,(05):483-508
Mundy,K. EDUCATION FOR ALL:Paradoxes and Prospects[A].Oxford UK:Elsevier,2007.1-31
Mundy,K. From NGOs to CSOs:Social Citizenship,Civil Society and "Education for All":An Agenda for Further Research[J].Current Issues in Comparative Edutation,2008,(02)
Mundy,K. Education for All and the Global Governors[A].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2010
Mundy,K,Iga,M. Hegemonic exceptionalism and legitimate bet-hedging:paradoxes and lessons from the US and Japanese approaches to education services under GATS[J].Globalisation Societies and Education,2003,(03):281-319
Mundy,K,Murphy,L. Transnational advocacy,global civil society:Emerging evidence from the field of education[J].Comparative Education Review,2001,(01):85-126.
Murphy,C.N. International organization and industrial change:Global governance since 1850[M].Cambridge:polity Press,1994
Novelli,M. The new geopolitics of educational aid:From Cold Wars to Holy Wars[J].International Journal of Educational Development,2010,(05):453-459
Novelli,M,S.Robertson. The Politicization of Development Aid to Education[OL].http://www
is.ac.uk/education/people/academicStaff/edslr/publications/politics_of_disaster,2007
O'Brien,R,Goetz,A.M,Scholte,J,Williams,M. Contesting global governance:multilateral economic institutions and global social movements[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2000.
Ottaway,M. Corporatism Goes Global:International organizations,nongovernmental networks and transnational business[J].Global Governance,2001,(03):265-292
Papadopoulos,G. Education 1960 1990:The OECD perspective[M].Paris:OECD,1994
Pauly,L,Grande,E. Complex sovereignty:Reconstituting political authority in the twenty-first century[M].Toronto:University of Toronto Press,2006.
Phillips,H.M. UNICEF and education:A historical perspective[M].New York:UNICEF,1987
Price,R,Reus-Smit C. Dangerous liaisons:Critical international theory and constructivism[J].European Journal of International Relations,1998,(03):259-294
Reinicke,W. Global public policy-.Governing without government[M].Washington,DC:Brookings institution,1989
Resnik,J. International organizations,the "education-economic growth" black box and the development of world education culture[J].Comparative Education Review,2006,(02):173-195
Risse,T. Global governance and communicative action[J].Government and Opposition,2004,(02):331-363
Robertson,S.L,Dale,R. New geographies of power in education:the politics of rescaling and its contradictions[A].Maindenhead:Open University Press,2006.
Robertson,S.L,Bonal,X,Dale,R. GATS and the education service industry:The politics of scale and global reterritorialization[J].Comparative Education Review,2002,(04):472-496.
Rosenau,J.N. Governance in the twenty-first century[A].New York:Routledge,2005
45-67
Ruggie,J.C. International regimes,transactions,and change:Embedded liberalism in the postwar economic order[J].International Organization,1982,(02):379-415
Ruggie,J.G. What makes the world hang together.Neo-utilitarianism and the social constructivist challenge[J].International Organization,1998,(04):855-885
Ruggie,J.C. Reconstituting the global public domain:Issues,actors and practices[J].European Journal of International Relations,2004,(04):499-531
Rupert,M. Class powers and the politics of global governance[A].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,2005.205-228
Samoff,J. Which priorities and strategies for education[J].International Journal of Educational Development,1996,(03):249-271
Scholte,J.A. Civil society and democratically accountable global governance[J].Government and Opposition,2005,(02):211-233
Schugurensky,D,A.Davidson-Harden. From C6rdoba to Washington:WTO/CATS and Latin American Education[J].Globalisation Societies and Education,2003,(03):321-357doi:101080/1476772032000141799
Silova,I,Steiner-Khamsi,G. How NGOs React:Globalization and Education Reform in the Caucasus,Central Asia,and Mongolia[M].Greenwich,CT:Kumarian Press,2008
Severino,J.M,O.Ray. The end of ODA and the Birth of Hypercollective Action[OL].http://www.cgdev.org/content/publications/detail/1424253,2010
Sewell,J.P. UNESCO and world politics:Engaging in international politics[M].Princeton,New Jersey:Princeton University Press,1975
Slaughter,A.M. Governing the global economy through government networks[A].New York:Pearson Longman,2005.124-140.
Smouts,M.C. The proper use of governance in international relations[J].International Social Science Journal,1998,(155):81-89
Soysal,Y.N. Locating Europe[J].European Societies,2002,(03):265-284
Stambach,A. Faith in schools:Religion,education,and American evangelicals in East Africa[M].Palo Alto:Stanford University Press,2010
Stone,D. Global Public Policy,Transnational Policy Communities and Their Networks[J].The Policy Studies Journal,2008.1,19-38
Srivastava,P,Oh,S. Private foundations,philanthropy,and partnership in education and development:Mapping the terrain[J].International Journal of Educational Developmen,2010,(05):460-471
Verger,A. The merchants of education:Global politics and the uneven education liberalization process in the WTO[J].Comparative Education Review,2009,(03):379-401
Verger,A. WTO/GATS and the global politics of education higher education[M].New York:Routledge,2009
Wallerstein,I. The politics of the world economy:The states,the movements and the civilisations[M].Cambridge:Cambridge University Press,1984
World Economic Forum. Global Education Initiative Annual Report 2009[R/OL].http://www.weforum.org/pdf/GEI/GEI_Annual_Report_2009
pdf,2009
[1] . 简讯[J]. 北京大学教育评论, 2016, 14(3): 83-83.
[2] 石中英. 重新思考毛泽东的教育思想遗产[J]. 北京大学教育评论, 2016, 14(3): 105-116.
[3] . 教育思想史研究:范式与方法[J]. 北京大学教育评论, 2015, 13(4): 1-1.
[4] 程天君. 教育改革的转型与教育政策的调整-基于新中国教育60年来的基本经验[J]. 北京大学教育评论, 2012, 10(4): 33-49.
[5] 庞丽娟,姜勇,洪秀敏. 迈向和谐的教师教育:问题与展望[J]. 北京大学教育评论, 2011, 9(1): 181-186.
[6] 张洪萍. 教育改革与政治制约-张百熙与京师大学堂的重建[J]. 北京大学教育评论, 2009, 7(3): 153-161.
[7] 尼克·温鲁普,简·范德瑞尔,鲍琳·梅尔. 教师知识和教学的知识基础[J]. 北京大学教育评论, 2008, 6(1): 21-38.
[8] 陈学飞,茶世俊. 理论导向的教育政策经验研究探析[J]. 北京大学教育评论, 2007, 5(4): 31-41.
[9] 林小英. 中国教育政策过程中的策略空间:一个对政策变迁的解释框架[J]. 北京大学教育评论, 2006, 4(4): 130-148.
[10] 金顶兵. 美国七所世界一流大学本科生专业选择的比较分析[J]. 北京大学教育评论, 2006, 4(3): 129-139.
[11] 李现平. 中国教育改革的辩证思考[J]. 北京大学教育评论, 2006, 4(1): 8-18.
[12] 马健生. 论教育改革方案的可接受性与可行性:公共选择的观点[J]. 北京大学教育评论, 2004, 2(4): 108-111.
[13] 劳凯声. 世纪之交的中国教育改革走向:教育与市场的关系问题[J]. 北京大学教育评论, 2003, 1(3): 10-16.
[14] 王蓉,岳昌君,李文利. 努力构筑我国公共教育财政体制(上)[J]. 北京大学教育评论, 2003, 1(2): 73-80.
Viewed
Full text


Abstract

Cited

首页 · 关于 · 关于OA · 法律公告 · 收录须知 · 联系我们 · 注册 · 登录


© 2015-2017 北京大学图书馆 .